EFF Tells Yet Another Court to Ensure Everyone Has Access to the Law and Reject Private Gatekeepers

2 months 2 weeks ago

Our laws belong to all of us, and we should be able to find, read, and comment on them free of registration requirements, fees, and other roadblocks. That means private organizations shouldn’t be able to control who can read and share the law, or where and how we can do those things. But that’s exactly what some industry groups are trying to do.

EFF has been fighting for years to stop them. The most recent instance is ASTM v. Upcodes. ASTM, an organization that develops technical standards, claims it retains copyright in those standards even when they’ve become binding law through “incorporation by reference.” When a standard is incorporated “by reference,” that means its text is not actually reprinted in the body of the government’s published regulations. Instead, the regulations include a citation to the standard, which means you have to track down a copy somewhere else if you want to know what the law requires.

 Incorporation by reference is common for a wide variety of laws governing the safety of buildings, pipelines, consumer products and so on. Often, these are laws that affect us directly in our everyday lives—but they can also be the most inaccessible. ASTM makes some of those laws available for free, but not all of them, and only via “reading rooms” that are hard to navigate and full of restrictions. Services like UpCodes have emerged to try to bridge the gap by making mandatory standards more easily available online. Among other things, UpCodes has created a searchable online library of some of the thousands of ASTM standards that have been incorporated by reference around the country. According to ASTM, that’s copyright infringement.

 EFF litigated a pair of cases on this issue for our client Public.Resource.Org (or “Public Resource”). We argued there that incorporated standards are the law, and no one can own copyright in the law. And in any event, it’s a fair use to republish incorporated standards in a centralized repository that makes them easier to access and use. In December 2023, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in Public Resource’s favor on fair use grounds.

 Based on our experience, we filed an amicus brief supporting UpCodes, joined by Public Knowledge and iFixit, Inc. and with essential support from local counsel Sam Silver and Abigail Burton at Welsh & Recker.  Unlike our cases for Public Resource, in UpCodes the standards at issue haven’t been directly incorporated into any laws. Instead, they’re incorporated by reference into other standards, which in turn have been incorporated into law. As we explain in our brief, this extra degree of separation shouldn’t make a difference in the legal analysis. If the government tells you, “Do what Document A says,” and Document A says, “Do what Document B says,” you’re going to need to read Document B to know what the government is telling you to do.

TAKE ACTION

Tell Congress: Access To Laws Should Be Fully Open

At the same time that we’re fighting this battle in the courts, we’re fighting a similar one in Congress. The Pro Codes Act would effectively endorse the claim that organizations like ASTM can “retain” copyright in codes, even after they are made law, as long as they make the codes available through a “publicly accessible” website—which means read-only, and subject to licensing limits. The Pro Codes Act recently fell short of the necessary votes to pass through the House, but it’s still being pushed by some lawmakers.

Whether it’s in courts or in Congress, we’ll keep fighting for your right to read and share the laws that we all must live by. A nation governed by the rule of law should not tolerate private control of that law. We hope the court in UpCodes comes to the same conclusion.

Cara Gagliano

【映画の鏡】今なぜ、自然への畏敬なのか『うんこと死体の復権』価値観覆し、命の循環の輪を=鈴木賀津彦

2 months 2 weeks ago
                                  2024「うんこと死体の復権」製作委員会 森の中での「野ぐそ」が、こんなにも素晴らしい価値を持った行為なのかと驚かされる。今やウオシュレットのない便器で用を足すことができなくなってしまった自分には「不可能だなぁ」と諦めながらも、蚊に刺されないためには何かしているのだろうかと心配しながら、楽しそうな「野ぐそ」にチャレンジしてみたくなってしまう不思議な作品だ。 排泄物という価値観を覆し、無数の生き物たちが命を..
JCJ

Weekly Report: DigiCertが発行した一部の証明書にドメイン検証不備があり失効を要することを公表

2 months 2 weeks ago
DigiCertはCNAMEベースのドメイン検証の不備により、一部の証明書を失効させる必要があると公表しました。影響を受ける組織には、DigiCertから個別に通知が行われています。DigiCertは、影響を受けた証明書の再発行を推奨しています。詳細は、DigiCertが提供する情報を参照してください。

【支部リポート】東海 イスラエル訪問に抗議 岐阜市長に批判集まる=丹原 美穂・加藤 剛

2 months 2 weeks ago
  岐阜市の柴橋正直市長は、5月27日から4日間の日程でイスラエルを訪問、宗教行事に参加したほか政府関係者との会合に参加するなどイスラエル支持の活動をした。 柴橋市長は「自費で行った。私的活動だ。信教の自由」と釈明したが、実際にはクリスチャンの政治家団体「オリーブの会」の会長としての訪問で、現地のユーチューブには「岐阜市長MAYOR OF GIFU CITY」と紹介されていた。このため岐阜9条の会、新日本婦人の会岐阜支部、市民のための市政を作る会、アラブ未来協会の4団体とイス..
JCJ